A Peanut Butter and Jellyfish Sandwich is food that is first shown in Freddi Fish and the Case of the Missing Kelp Seeds.
Freddi Fish and the Case of the Missing Kelp SeedsEdit
In order to get into any of the three caves, Freddi and Luther will need to give this sandwich to Eddie the Eel as he won't let the duo pass him unless his hunger is satisfied (and they don't want to give themselves up for him). After Freddi gives the sandwich to Eddie, he lets the duo pass and leaves. This is completely optional, unless the player needs to get the bottle from one of the three caves.
Theses sandwiches act as the number of tries Freddi has throughout the levels. Each time an enemy touches Freddi, she is forced to give up a sandwich, which the enemy eats. If Freddi has no more sandwiches to give up, the game is over. Freddi can get extra sandwiches to gain extra tries.