Vanilla is an item found in Fatty Bear's Birthday Surprise.
Fatty Bear's Birthday Surprise Edit
Fatty Bear will need vanilla in order to make Kayla's birthday cake. Fatty Bear will find the vanilla in the center cabinet above the kitchen counter. After Fatty Bear is in the kitchen with the vanilla, he will automatically place the vanilla on the counter.
When used for making the vanilla, Fatty Bear will need to input one teaspoon of vanilla into the mixing bowl.